We love giving our kids gifts. Birthdays, Christmas, St. Nick boots, stockings, and the occasional random Tuesday when we find something we KNOW they'll love. It’s a highlight of our lives to give our kids the things we wanted when we were young.
To set the stage, we are not minimalists. If you saw our playroom or our house at Christmas, you would know that. LOL. Everyone has their own ridiculous Christmas tree :) Our kids have toys, books, things they love, things they've outgrown, knick knacks and probably a few things we forgot we even owned.
We're not rejecting the generosity of our family or saying our children shouldn't receive presents. We've just become much more intentional about what we bring into our home and what we want our kids to value.
The reality is that a gift has a life after it's been opened, and someone in the household becomes primarily responsible for that life. There is a real mental load that comes with having too much stuff, and while people may feel good giving a gift, what ends up happening is that it tethers ME, the mom, to constantly picking it up. And my husband hears about it :)
While the gift is in the giving, it can saddle us with wasted time caring for the item. Putting it back in its "home," making a home for it, cleaning it, fixing it and multiplying that by 100 items each week and then by the number of kids in the household. At some point, it really isn't a gift anymore, it becomes a burden.
Toy clutter changes the dynamic in our house. I get cranky and end up fighting over keeping the house tidy. Not even spotless, just picked up so I can run the Roomba.
When I think about what I want for our family, it's time together and parents who are mentally free to spend that time with our kids. And I can't be that parent if I'm drowning in "stuff."
When James was probably five or six, I remember being so angry that I was spending what little "free time" I had yelling at him about the mess he was making with toys all over the place. And I thought, oh my gosh, two things need to happen.
First, I need to teach him what it actually means to clean and tidy. I deep cleaned every room and took pictures and put the finished product on the wall so he had a visual reference of what it needed to look like.
Second, I realized my expectations were astronomical for a kid his age because LOOK at all of the things we have to manage!
If it's overwhelming for me, it's surely overwhelming for him.
I realized that expecting a young child to independently manage an overwhelming amount of toys wasn't realistic. We needed to change both how we taught him to care for his things and how much stuff we were bringing into our home to ease the load.
Our language about things transitioned, too. We now talk about what we would prefer, what we're prioritizing, and give examples.
Like this past week when James circled TEN Squishies in the Target holiday magazine.
I asked him, "James, you know if I buy you ten Squishies, that takes away money from something like a fun family trip. Would you rather have ten Squishies? Or an experience like going to Australia and maybe getting one Squishy?"
When I explained that we're operating on a budget and we need to think about how we spend our money, he chose the trip over the toys.
We’re teaching that choices have trade offs and sometimes experiences are worth more than the stuff. I'd argue that we actually learn more about our world and ourselves through experiences than a house filled with toys that get used once.
The Gifts We Actually Love
We have very meaningful, long-term gifts that have proven their weight in gold. Open-ended toys that can be used for years are our favorite: water tables, our ChompSaw, specialty characters, LEGO, etc.
We're not opposed to having things. We just want the things we have to serve a purpose, whether that's entertainment, learning, creativity, or simply something our kids genuinely enjoy. We also love gifts that support experiences.
Now, What Happens When We're Done With a Gift?
We don't feel obligated to hold on to gifts that no longer serve their purpose. The gift was in the giving, full stop. When our kids have outgrown something or no longer use it, we send it along to someone else who will make new memories with it. We also keep some toys in the basement and rotate them out, and we do the same with books organized by season. We aren't trying to eliminate everything, we’re just trying to make what we have manageable.
How We Handle Gifts From Family and Friends
We've communicated our preferences to our families, we haven't had too much pushback, and we don't reject gifts.
We're simply sharing what would be most helpful for our family, whether that's a contribution toward an activity, a subscription, or a physical gift that our kids will genuinely enjoy. We've communicated to our families that it would be more helpful for us if they contributed to swimming lessons, tumbling, and activities like that. They appreciate spending money on something that will be valued too! We've even suggested magazine subscriptions because our kids love getting mail! Some favorites include Highlights, Honest History, and The Week Junior. These are gifts that keep giving without necessarily adding another pile of toys to manage.
We also say "no gifts" at birthday parties because I know not every family is able to give a gift, and I want everyone to feel comfortable attending. Some families still bring gifts and that's completely ok. Our kids will open presents with family, and that's enough.
And yes, we still celebrate birthdays and Christmas with presents. We do St. Nick boots and Christmas stockings, too. Being intentional about gifting also allows us to grab things throughout the year without guilt when we find something we know will be well received.
Has It Actually Made a Difference?
Absolutely.
We have so much less arguing about cleaning and feel significantly less overwhelmed by the amount of stuff in our home. I yell so much less! And when it does come time to clean the house, it takes maybe 15–30 minutes to pick up the entire main floor not because we have an empty house, but because everything has a home and everyone knows where that home is.
That's a pretty significant difference from spending my limited free time frustrated and yelling about toys being everywhere. For us, having less to manage means having more time and energy for the people in our home and that’s really what we want right?
What We're Really Trying to Give Our Kids
I don't want my kids to grow up thinking that every holiday, birthday, or special occasion needs to come with an overwhelming number of presents. I want them to appreciate what they have, understand that we make choices about how we spend our money, and recognize that experiences can be just as valuable as things. I want them to learn that we don't have to keep something forever just because someone gave it to us (this took me decades to learn).
We want our children to have wonderful things and wonderful experiences AND I want them to grow up in a home where we're not constantly frustrated with one another over piles of stuff.