When it comes to extracurricular activities, our goal as a family has always been to give our kids opportunities to explore their interests without sacrificing our family's time, finances, energy, or sanity.
We've tried activities and sports, abandoned some, waited until our kids were ready, and made decisions based on what actually works for our family as a whole. Some activities have been surprising successes, while others have been expensive reminders that just because something is available and someone else is doing it, doesn't mean we need to do it too (I’m looking at you toddler soccer…).
I want our kids to experience new things, develop skills, discover their strengths, and figure out what they genuinely enjoy. But I also want us to have weekends that aren't completely booked, evenings that don't feel rushed, and enough energy left over to actually enjoy being together.
Ultimately, we're trying to be intentional about the opportunities we provide, recognizing that every activity comes with a commitment from the entire family.
The Family Logistics Nobody Talks About
Choosing extracurricular activities involves much more than finding something our kids might enjoy. We have to consider our finances, availability, transportation, and energy.
I have an autoimmune disease that can cause significant exhaustion, particularly with too much activity or prolonged exposure to heat and sun. Because of our work and sleep schedules as parents, I'm also generally the primary adult responsible for transportation.
Sometimes it makes more sense for our youngest to stay home with her dad while I take James to an evening activity. That arrangement works better for her bedtime routine, too.
We also have weekly tutoring, which is another commitment we've chosen because we want to stay on top of academics before a problem arises.
Weekly tutoring is important to us because academics build on themselves. We want to make sure our kids have a solid foundation before moving on to the next topics. We'd rather identify and address gaps in understanding early than wait until they're struggling with concepts that build on skills they haven't fully mastered yet.
The reality is that an extracurricular activity might be for one child, but the commitment belongs to the entire family.
The Activities We've Tried
In a world that feels like kids are over scheduled, here’s where we’ve landed in regards to extracurricular activities and how they fit into our neurodiverse family.
Little Kid Soccer
We tried Saturday morning soccer when our son was little. It was crowded, loud, expensive, and honestly, not particularly enjoyable for any of us. At that point in time too we had undiagnosed ADHD and needed glasses so things just were not working out.
The thing is, everyone was doing little kid soccer so I felt like a bad mom if I didn’t enroll my son. I enrolled because of MY feelings!
We tried two seasons in a row then stopped, then started again when we asked if he wanted to try again and ultimately at the end of the third class we didn’t return.
For me this was a 2/10.
Dance
We enrolled both of our children in dance through their early childhood centers. It was fun, convenient, and didn't interfere with our evenings or weekends. Every spring, the kids had opportunities to participate in a recital.
I loved watching James dance. He loves to dance and he’s naturally very good at it. I think him having the opportunity to work with a team, follow directions at a young age and perform on a stage all helped develop his self confidence.
I absolutely love the convenience of having extracurriculars at the daycare, like dance.
Watching James be completely comfortable and enthralled with being on stage was a blast.
For me this was a 10/10.
German School
I speak Spanish and wanted to raise my kids bilingual. James, my oldest, refused to speak Spanish with me, so we tried Saturday morning French school which we loved!
The French School pivoted during COVID (as did most of us) and we never got back into a routine of going.
By the time the world opened up again, I had found a German School which was equally as well organized and a bit closer to home.
By heritage our family is German, so we enrolled James in Saturday morning German school when he started first grade. He could have started earlier, but we wanted him to have a year of traditional school under his belt before introducing something else new.
German school meets for three hours on Saturday mornings during the academic year. I know this sounds like a lot but hear me out - the kids have snack time and outdoor recess, along with opportunities to participate in German cultural traditions like Schultüte, Laternenumzug, German-American Day, and a Christmas recital. Some classes they work on building “Munich” out of Lego, and learning about famous German musicians. I give this a 10/10 - they do a great job.
Swim Team
Between second and third grade, James participated in our neighborhood swim team, and I enjoyed it much more than I expected.
To be clear from the get go I was anti-swim team because it’s an outdoor activity and I am sensitive to sunlight and heat LOL (where my autoimmune girlies at?). Also, it required adult volunteering which is difficult when you have an 8yr old and a 2yr old and a parent that works nights.
Beyond developing his swimming skills, which I consider incredibly important from a safety standpoint, he got to experience working toward personal and team goals. I met some great parents and I got to watch my son take ownership of his abilities and advocate for himself when he needed help. The summer swim schedule was intense but short.
Fencing
In third grade, at age eight, James started fencing.
One of his above-average strengths is pattern recognition, so we started looking for activities where that skill could be an advantage. We discovered several fencing clubs around St. Louis. Unfortunately, we're located right smack in between all of them, so fencing requires a bit of driving.
Still, it's been a fun opportunity for him to learn something new, challenge himself physically, and work toward improving his skills. We have found the absolute best people in the fencing crew - his coach is 10/10 very patient and works so well with the class. He has found it challenging to not be excellent right away. I give this a 10/10.
Music
We tried piano in kindergarten (back when I was like “If we just get started eventually everything will come together”), but we didn't have a good handle on his attention and readiness at that point, so we paused. James wants to be a rock and roll guitarist so we met with an instructor who suggested we wait on the guitar for a bit. I personally think piano would be the easiest way to learn to read music and then add in guitar, but we’ll see how things go when we get to fourth grade. Our goal is to re-introduce a musical instrument again in fourth grade.
Summer Camps
We've also enrolled our oldest in weeklong summer camps covering fitness, general sports, basketball, and tennis, art, robotics, rocketry, you name it!
These camps, often at the community college, give him opportunities to experience different activities without requiring a season-long commitment. When he expresses genuine interest in something, we make an effort to explore it further.
School-Based Clubs
Similar to how daycare had dance class during the daycare day at the center, I’m really thankful for early morning extracurriculars at our elementary school. James gets to participate in a comic book club and chess club!
Why We're Intentional About Our Schedule
We want our children to have opportunities to learn, grow, try new things, and discover what they enjoy. But we don't want every evening spent rushing between activities or every weekend completely booked.
We want time to be home. Time to rest. Time to be together without somewhere else we need to be. We're not against having a busy schedule. We're against being busy simply for the sake of being busy - and oh my gosh this took me a long time to learn. I felt this unexplainable pressure to enroll my son in all the activities everyone else was doing and it was overwhelming to me! What changed my thinking about the pressure to enroll our kids in so many activities was watching how they behaved when they were overscheduled. They were tired, cranky, and upset. It wasn't healthy, and at that point, the activities were doing more harm than good. We were signing them up for activities because we thought we were giving them opportunities, but we weren't necessarily considering what those opportunities were costing them. That's when we realized we needed to be much more intentional about how we spent our time and energy as a family.
Overscheduled for us means: No time to be bored or rest or be alone. No time to eat regular meals. This is especially important for us because with neurodivergence in our family, we need time to take breaks.
Enrolling our son in multiple activities after school during the week was a recipe for meltdowns. It’s a lot of work to self monitor around people all day and I am very mindful of making sure our kids don’t have to get up and go to activities every night of the week. We’re not competing with the families who have more sports lined up than us, or join select teams - that just doesn’t work for our family…right now. Maybe in the future but who knows?
One thing I’m really proud of us for doing is waiting to enroll our kiddos in activities. That has been clutch in making decisions to enroll our kids in activities, not just sports. The extra maturity makes a huge difference. Even when we met with professionals about enrolling in guitar and fencing they recommended waiting until age 8 and I’m glad that we did.
We're Playing the Long Game
All of the choices we’ve made are based on our own children’s needs and development - other kids will be different!I don't know whether James will still be fencing in five years, whether he'll love learning an instrument, or whether either of my kids will develop some lifelong passion from the activities we've chosen. And that's okay. I don't think the goal is to find their thing as quickly as possible. I think the goal is to give them opportunities to figure out who they are, what they enjoy, and what they're capable of while still having enough time and energy left over to enjoy being a family. Ultimately what I want my kids to gain from these experiences:
Learn about their likes and dislikes. Learn how their brain reacts to disappointment and struggle and how their brain reacts to winning.
Learn how to tolerate frustration, learn how to work towards a goal, learn how to be a good team member. Develop problem solving skills. Learn about other people and cultures. There is so much history and culture and language tied to German and fencing and swimming.
A Note About Privilege
We have the finances and the flexibility of time to offer lots of opportunities.
We also, in place of physical presents for our kids (calm down, they get a lot of presents and stuff…they want for nothing) we have opted to suggest to family members to purchase gift cards for extra curricular activities (but I’ll talk more about our gifting in another post).